Finding Our Way Together on Election Day, November 3

Two different commentators I listened to this morning on podcasts (Ezra Klein interviewing Nate Silver and Nicolle Wallace interviewing Heather Cox Richardson) suggested that big change could be coming our way with the November 3 mid-term elections. America got a big shock in 2016 with Donald Trump’s victory and Hillary Clinton’s defeat. But I sensed from these analysts that this could be even bigger.

Nate Silver suggested that Tuesday night could usher in an era of “momentous change.” Heather Cox Richardson told Nicolle Wallace that we may see a sea change in American politics as Americans seem to be, finally, catching on to the staggering corruption of the Trump administration and that, not only does he not conceal it, but he also flaunts it.

Americans who struggle to buy groceries, gasoline, health care, and pay for education for themselves and their families do not accept the need for trade wars and more war in the Middle East. Voters have ceased to believe promises of a great economic boom after the first of the year, conveniently predicted to follow the mid-term elections.

Furthermore, they know the smell of a rat when they are each promised a check for $5,000 if a particular party’s candidate wins the senate election in their state. That is slime of a higher viscosity than most Americans will tolerate.

So we wait to see what the voters decide. The administration has done all it can to confuse voters and instill distrust in the election system. But the system keeps on working. Poll workers continue to volunteer even in the face of threats from the very people who should be assuring them support and protection to do one of the fundamental jobs in a democracy—the conduct of free and fair elections.

My gratitude goes out to the people who invest some of their agency over and above the right to vote by doing the real shitwork of democracy. They get all the voting equipment and materials to polling places in time for the polls to open at 7 a.m. They work all day past the closing of polls at 7 p.m. to make sure everyone follows rules. Then, assuming there are no lines that are allowed to vote after 7 p.m., they pack it all up to get it to their county courthouse or election center. And they listen to people complain all day long about long lines, the way stations have been set up, shortages of materials, etc., etc.

My wife and I used to do this for $5 an hour. Even at the current rate of $12, no one gets rich being a poll worker. In addition to working hard for long hours, these days they put up with public abuse from election deniers bent on undermining the election process.

So, be nice to the people who are making it possible for you to apply your agency and maybe, just maybe, we can make this a better world. Give them your thanks even if you know them and know that they always support that “other” party. After all, this is a community, not a boxing arena. Without that “other” party to keep discussions lively and elections competitive, democracy would die a slow death while we just stand by and watch one of history’s greatest achievements wither away and we return to a world governed by kings and other autocrats. Commit yourself to honoring the agency of every human being by yourself being an active part of this democracy.

The very least you can do is vote.

The Power We Have—and the Choice to Use It

When I listen to political discussions on television and podcasts, I often hear “agency” used to mean a person’s or organization’s ability to make decisions and act independently. I had previously associated the word with nonprofit and government organizations, not individuals. This broader meaning gives me a way to think about our power and responsibility as citizens: what we can decide for ourselves, and how we act on those decisions. Maybe it is a handy new buzzword, but the question it raises is worth discussing: how do we exercise our agency as citizens?

  • Who has agency in American society?
  • Do some people have more of it than others?

In our civics classes in public schools years ago, we never talked about citizenship as agency. Citizenship had responsibilities and duties. Citizenship was a right and it came with duties. One of them was to vote. And we learned the rules. In any election, each citizen had one vote and the candidate or proposition with the most votes won the day.

In a democratic society, a person’s vote is one atom in the whole body of social will. Each of us asserts agency through voting, as well as in other ways. But the vote is our most fundamental power. One vote is equal to any other person’s vote in a democracy when everyone votes.

But voting in most democracies is voluntary. Twenty-two democracies make voting compulsory. The United States is one of the voluntary voting nations. Here in the U.S. You are free to not vote.

Not voting increases the agency of every person who does vote. Within the smaller group of voters each voter has proportionally more power than any non-voter in determining a jurisdiction’s will with respect to candidates and ballot propositions. And candidates interpret the size of their majority as a mandate to achieve campaign promises.

Voting is not the only way we exercise agency. We can also express our views more directly to the legislators we elected to represent us. Even when we were in the minority in an election or disagree with a legislator on an issue, our opinions still deserve to be heard. By writing or calling our representatives, we remind them that we are still here and that we will hold them accountable at the next election. That works even when we talk to an assistant or leave a recorded message.

Our agency is more than our vote. The freedoms of expression, assembly and the press expand our agency even more. They provide other ways of gaining information and expressing our opinions in ways that can move the legislative needle and perhaps build new majorities.

Summing up, our agency as citizens in a democracy is an asset we should treasure and use. Authoritarian governments place agency fully in the hands of a single leader or group of oligarchs. The agency of individual citizens is mostly limited to the collective action of large groups protesting in the streets. And that often becomes deadly.

We have risen above that kind of government in the United States. Please help us keep it by using your agency and going to the polls to vote in this midterm election.

Let’s Have a Conversation

I have resisted writing here lately because my feelings about our politics are strong and I didn’t want to add to the toxicity of America’s current political discussion. But I have concluded that our society and our politics are in such a calamitous state that each citizen needs to do their best to help show the way to personal, political and societal salvation.

And it needs to be shared. America needs this discussion. I will try offer my small part and I will do it with love and respect for every American and all the people of the world.

Love and respect for the people with whom I agree is relatively easy. The president and all the people who call themselves MAGA or MAHA Republicans present the greater challenge as they would almost certainly not extend grace to me or anyone in the “Democrat” Party. But it isn’t really grace if you extend it only to the people you call friends.

Granted, it is hard to love and respect anyone who takes control of a government and operates it like a criminal syndicate. But we gave him that power through an electoral process that had served us well throughout our history, at least for the most part. So, there is little point in focusing the discussion on him.

Extending grace, love and respect to the people with whom we differ politically does not mean that they should be exempt them from legally established control and punishment. We are all subject to the law.

Removing the president from office may seem appropriate to his political opponents but that power is held by the legislative branch. He has been twice impeached by the House of Representatives but acquitted both times by the Republican majority in the Senate. Those of the president’s party who voted to convict are mostly leaving the Senate rather than face his retribution.

But this is only one area where the Republican congress has ducked for cover. It has refused to hold the administration accountable for its immigration policy and enforcement debacle, the wars against Iran and Venezuela, and full release of the files that document extensive wrongdoings of Jeffrey Epstein and his many monied friends. They have ignored corruption and looked the other way while the president has made a business of privatizing currency through what amounts to a Ponzi scheme.

I could go on. But, in brief, our government has failed.

Over the next few days and weeks, we can look at some things we all can do to right the ship and make our government work for the welfare of the people once again.

I will share my thoughts with you. I hope you will offer your own thoughts as comments at the end of this article.

An Unrelenting Gnawing at My Soul

The Listeners by Walter De La Mare

Public Domain, link copied from

http://www.poetryfoundation.org

‘Is there anybody there?’ said the Traveller,   

   Knocking on the moonlit door; 

And his horse in the silence champed the grasses   

   Of the forest’s ferny floor: 

And a bird flew up out of the turret,   

   Above the Traveller’s head: 

And he smote upon the door again a second time;   

   ‘Is there anybody there?’ he said. 

But no one descended to the Traveller;   

   No head from the leaf-fringed sill 

Leaned over and looked into his grey eyes,   

   Where he stood perplexed and still. 

But only a host of phantom listeners   

   That dwelt in the lone house then 

Stood listening in the quiet of the moonlight   

   To that voice from the world of men: 

Stood thronging the faint moonbeams on the dark stair,   

   That goes down to the empty hall, 

Hearkening in an air stirred and shaken   

   By the lonely Traveller’s call. 

And he felt in his heart their strangeness,   

   Their stillness answering his cry, 

While his horse moved, cropping the dark turf,   

   ’Neath the starred and leafy sky; 

For he suddenly smote on the door, even   

   Louder, and lifted his head:— 

‘Tell them I came, and no one answered,   

   That I kept my word,’ he said. 

Never the least stir made the listeners,   

   Though every word he spake 

Fell echoing through the shadowiness of the still house   

   From the one man left awake: 

Ay, they heard his foot upon the stirrup,   

   And the sound of iron on stone, 

And how the silence surged softly backward,   

   When the plunging hoofs were gone.

–\\\\\–

Well, here I am again. I tried to give up this bad habit of paying good money to people so I could write things for other people to read. I managed to successfully stop it a few years ago with respect to what I had come to think of as the loathsome Facebook . In this comeback posting, I begin by quoting someone else’s poetry, maybe as a way of trying to explain myself.

Last year I committed myself to discontinuing this WordPress chronicle. I had written about the things I thought about and worried about; I wrote about my church and its internal debates over social principles; I wrote about my community’s fine arts council and its theater programs, and, in general, many things that are not of interest to most readers. Besides, what do I really have to say about political issues that has not already either been born or batted around online? I read the opinion pages in national papers and I know that there are many better educated and informed people saying the things that needed to be said regarding our civic lives. Saying it all here seemed to benefit no one but myself and an irrepressible egotistical desire to attract attention. I let my subscription to the service run out. But then I wavered again.

WordPress gave me another chance to re-up, as online services almost always do. And I did. I renewed the service and will be here at least through April of 2027. So why did I decide to continue?

Most importantly WordPress emphasizes content rather than user relationships. As I remember it, people typically used Facebook posts to craft a story of their lives as they wanted friends to see them: wealthier than they really are, cooler than they really are and more well read than they really are. And, of course, kinder than they really are to their precious pets which are presented as cuter than they really are. And they undoubtedly wanted you to see it and ‘friend’ them or give them a ‘like’.

It would be disingenuous to say that I am not interested in presenting my life as one of distinction. People who know me know that I try to post things I have spent some time thinking about not just what I had for breakfast, or the cute thing my cat, kid or dog did nor my immediate reaction to what I saw on the evening news or picked up online. I do my very best (most of the time) to say something I really need to say because of its informational or moral relevance for readers and all the people in this world we share.

I don’t fish for readers. What I think about and write is here for anyone who reads it. In fact, I heard a little poem today on the podcast Poetry Unbound. The title is “The Listeners.” It is in the public domain and I led this discussion with it.

When I read the Walter De La Mare poem, I see myself as the Traveller as I send these chronicles out to phantom listeners (readers). And you would be one of them. Not just to you, but to that phantom being we call a soul. Whatever it is that I need to say, it is of ultimate concern to me and it is my responsibility to let anyone within reach of my voice know that I came and that I kept my word. These are things I must say because it is a duty of citizens to speak and, especially, of things that constitute one’s ultimate concerns.

If no one answers my knock, still, I am keeping my word. It is important to me to come calling on you because I have been feeling lately a gnawing at my soul: the world is rotting all around me and people who see something must say something.

Is anybody there? May my soul speak with yours?

Once more: From Hell

Well, good morning from Hell again.

I know you are wondering how I can call this Hell if I can’t even talk about our duly elected president, Congress, and his appointed and confirmed courts. I have dismissed him and his Space-Cadet-in-Chief from our discussion because it would be altogether too easy to assign them all the blame, remove them from office someday, and we would still have — Hell. Even if we rid ourselves of the governing powers in Texas. Yes, still Hell.

Obviously I’m not talking about an eternity in that fiery underground furnace we heard about as children or the one considered credible by many Christians, but the one we live in every day.  Even if we include Texas politics, we wouldn’t quite drop to that level. And it does promise to be another hot summer in Texas here south of town.

The hell I’m talking about and the one we live in today and every day is the one:

— Where people’s rights are extinguished by the power of the state. That’s one aspect of the hell of everyday life in this world. If you don’t feel that this applies to you, good for you. But it is still hell for most of the people inhabiting our planet, including many who live in this country. Yes — our citizens, too.

— Where weapons are easily accessible and where teenagers use them to settle arguments and to express their frustrations with the institutions they encounter on a daily basis, or even their parents. Where they use them, not for sport, but to kill. That’s another aspect of Hell. If your child has not been shot at school or shot someone, it’s still Hell that you live in every day even if it comes your way only as fear or maybe the guilt you feel for being a part of a civic culture that has allowed it.

— Where there is starvation on a prosperous and resource-rich planet. Where low-cost, starchy, fat-laden, salty and sugar-loaded fast foods fill the diets of children instead of balanced meals around family tables. Where many children in other parts of our planet simply starve to death. Not even a McDonald’s to fill their stomachs.

— Where people suffer and die needlessly in a nation, indeed a world, of seemingly limitless medical knowledge and ability. It’s what happens in Hell.

— Where we encourage some to profit from our burning fuel that exhausts a suffocating gas into the air — air that is no less than the essence of God’s breath.

— Where religions persist in holding onto conflicting beliefs that are no longer of service to either man or God, then dedicate themselves to wiping out those who disagree with them. People are left searching for the moral and unifying leadership that could help them find a better life for themselves and all the other people on the planet. And while they search, the princes of Hell have their way.

This was a hell that existed long before we allowed any particular political leadership to come to power. All of it was building for all the millennia of our existence. We might even have found a name for it — call it original sin. And no, there are no exceptions. We all own it. We either enjoy its supposed benefits or we enjoy profits from the production and distribution of Hell’s products. 

And all political parties and all countries own it. It was not invented by the Republicans or the Democrats. Nor was it invented by our duly elected president. He has just openly enjoyed its perfection for his own benefit more than any other president. A $400,000,000 luxury airliner from a foreign power he does business with through his family? Only a loser would say, “No, thank you” and walk away.

Many of us were taught to think of sin in individual and sexual terms. But that is so limiting. And it leaves us free to benefit from all the pleasures Hell can produce for a few at the expense of the many — the least, the last and the lost. 

Think about the House version of the Big Beautiful Budget and tax bill. Huge tax breaks for billionaires and more modest ones for middle class people, paid for in part by cuts to Medicaid, SNAP (food stamps) and other vital services for low income families and individuals. If you are one of the middle class Christian voters whose silence is bought by those minuscule tax cuts, square that with your Holy Communion prayer:

Merciful God, we confess that we have not loved you with our whole heart. We have failed to be an obedient church. We have not done your will, we have broken your law, we have rebelled against your love, we have not loved our neighbors, and we have not heard the cry of the needy. Forgive us, we pray. Free us for joyful obedience, through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.

This Hell has many aspects that this little essay does not even touch. Privatization of almost anything for profit. Prisons. Schools. Monetary systems. Wanna buy a $trump memecoin? Now, there’s a Ponzi scheme that operates at an international level right out of our Oval Office.

Yes, it dawned here in Hell this morning, already sunny to partly cloudy and hot. And it’s promising to get even even hotter over the years and centuries.

Some in this hell have worked every day to perfect automata that can survive our physically frail humanity with an artificial intelligence unweighted by thoughts of beauty, justice, love and altruism — each one of them a winner designed and encased to thrive in whatever climate and temperature Hell might serve up. 

Humanity, as we know it, is but a distant memory in the circuits of whatever it is that may survive us. Maybe the robots of the future will think of the humanity of the past as God. More likely, they will have been programmed to see us as a bunch of losers.

But there was a man in our history who tried to help us understand what people do when motivated solely by self-interest. He taught that there was a better way to live — we could make this into heaven, here and now. We could all learn much from his teaching. Think about that and find a place to attend a service this coming Sunday.

There were leaders who founded other religions and denominations teaching similar concepts. But Jesus is the one I have studied more fully as a United Methodist Christian.

If worship doesn’t appeal to you,  think of it as study. See if you can identify that church’s vision of heaven from the songs, sermons, prayers and the welcoming behavior of the people you meet.  If the vision you see does not seem consistent with the vision of the gospels, maybe you should find another church, denomination, or even religion. There are other religions whose practices are more consistent with the teachings of Jesus than those of a good many nominally Christian churches and denominations. And, in any case, God’s grace reaches out to all mankind.

And if you can’t quite bring yourself to get up and go to church somewhere, come back here on Monday and I’ll do the preaching.


Good Morning from Hell

Hell?

This doesn’t seem like Hell. There’s this long and beautiful marriage, two wonderful children and five grandchildren — all of them perfect. A church and a center for arts and sciences with friendships of many years. The pantry is full. The AC keeps me comfortable day and night. I have more doctors than I once had school teachers in high school. My church is involved in mission projects, a food pantry, assisting in a local elementary school, and help for people in need of financial assistance. And if I need, more likely just want, a new electronic toy, Amazon can have it on my doorstep tomorrow. Some of us are getting along quite well.

But something is amiss in our politics.

The president’s authoritarian character is not news anymore. I refer you to well documented reporting in established national media. The president, of course, denies anything that doesn’t glorify him and he decries “mainstream journalism” as creators and bearers of “fake news.”

But that’s just another tool in the authoritarian’s toolkit. 

I will also spare you the well-worn comparisons with Hitler, Mussolini, and Stalin. Those can be found anywhere except maybe in Fox media, controlled by the Rupert Murdock family, or the many informational hellholes you can read into on social media. 

However, if you discard these comparisons as illogical name-calling, I refer you to The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich, a report on events in Germany in the 1930s by a CBS and UPI reporter, William L. Shirer. Adolph Hitler was Shirer’s subject with a tip of the journalist’s hat to Benito Mussolini and our ally in the European war against fascism, Joseph Stalin.

But I suspect Hitler did not consider either CBS or UPI to be a credible news source. 

Shirer’s book is one of those thick ones. You may not choose it for bedtime reading.  But if you do, follow it up with On Tyranny: Twenty Lessons from the Twentieth Century by Timothy Snider. That’s a short one and easy to read. Invest a few dollars and put it down beside your evening devotional guide. Read a chapter every night before you say your prayers. You will pray more fervently.

So forget about Trump for awhile if you can. Forget all about what many see as readily apparent indicators of an authoritarian future for the United States of America. Think, instead, about where we live now and where we have lived throughout the lives of most of us — Hell.

Really? How could one possibly call this Hell?

More tomorrow about the hell we live in and how it looks from the south of town.